SIP vs FD Calculator

Compare what the same monthly amount could grow to via a SIP versus an FD/RD, at your own assumed rates.

Formula

SIP maturity: Standard SIP future-value formula

FD/RD maturity: Standard Recurring Deposit compounding formula

What is the SIP vs FD Calculator?

A SIP vs FD calculator takes one monthly amount and runs it through two very different homes: a mutual fund SIP at an expected market return, and a recurring deposit at a fixed bank rate. It then shows both maturity values and the difference between them.

This is the comparison many Indian families make when they first consider mutual funds. Bank deposits are familiar and guaranteed; SIPs promise more but carry risk. Putting the same rupees, the same months and your own rate assumptions side by side turns a vague debate into a concrete number.

The FD side is modelled as a recurring deposit because an ordinary FD takes a lump sum, while this comparison is about saving every month.

How to calculate it by hand

1. Fix the monthly amount P, the period N years, the expected SIP return Rs% and the RD rate Rf%.

2. SIP side: with i = Rs ÷ 1200 and n = 12N, FV = P × [((1 + i)ⁿ − 1) ÷ i] × (1 + i).

3. RD side: each instalment compounds quarterly for its remaining time. For instalment m, value = P × (1 + Rf ÷ 400)^(4 × (n − m + 1) ÷ 12).

4. Add all n RD instalment values to get the RD maturity.

5. Difference = SIP maturity − RD maturity.

6. Before deciding, adjust both for tax and think about how much risk the SIP adds.

Same money, different compounding rules

Both sides invest P every month for n months, so the total invested is identical. The SIP formula compounds monthly at the SIP rate, with each instalment invested at the start of its month. The RD side follows the usual Indian bank convention of quarterly compounding, applied to each instalment for the number of months it stays deposited. So the comparison isolates two things: the rate difference and the compounding convention. Over short periods the gap is small; over 15 or 20 years a few percentage points of rate difference produce a large rupee gap.

The SIP number is an assumption, the RD number is not

The RD rate is written into the deposit receipt and will be paid unless the bank fails, and bank deposits carry DICGC insurance up to a limit. The SIP rate is your estimate of average equity returns. Actual returns may be higher or lower, and in any three-year window they can even be negative. So the difference shown is the reward you expect for bearing market risk, not a sure gain. A fair test is to rerun the SIP side at a cautious rate and see whether it still beats the RD.

Tax changes the gap

RD interest is added to your income and taxed at your slab rate every year, even though you receive it only at maturity, and banks may deduct TDS. Equity mutual fund gains are taxed only when you redeem, under capital gains rules that are generally lighter than slab rates for long holdings. For someone in a high tax bracket, the post-tax gap is often wider than the pre-tax gap this calculator shows. For a person with little taxable income, the tax difference may hardly matter.

Worked example, step by step

Lakshmi can set aside ₹7,500 a month for 10 years. Her bank's RD pays 6.75%, and she thinks a large-cap SIP could average 11%.

Answer: SIP maturity value ₹16,42,405; FD/RD maturity value ₹12,84,939; Difference ₹3,57,466

Common mistakes to avoid

Treating the SIP maturity as certain and the difference as guaranteed extra money.

Comparing post-tax FD returns with pre-tax SIP returns, or the other way round.

Using a short period such as two or three years, where equity risk is highest.

Forgetting that many banks offer senior citizens a higher RD rate.

Putting emergency money in a SIP because the long-term number looks better.

Where it is used

Helping a first-time investor see the trade-off between guaranteed and market-linked savings.

Deciding how to split monthly savings between an RD and a SIP.

Showing why short-term goals suit deposits and long-term goals suit equity.

Testing how sensitive the conclusion is to a lower SIP return.

Frequently asked questions

Is a SIP always better than an FD?

Not necessarily — a SIP has a higher expected return over the long run, but no guarantee, and it can lose value in a bad market. An FD guarantees its rate but usually loses to inflation less dramatically than it beats it. Most financial planners suggest holding both, matched to different goals and time horizons.

Loading Gananayantra…